
I just finished reading Axis, the second novel in a series by Robert Charles Wilson. While technically the sequel to his earlier work, Spin, the two books share nothing other than setting and one character. There is very little overlap between the novels, and frankly Axis just isn’t as good as Spin. some of that might well be because the paint has started to wear off of the universe. Axis did not inspire the kind of pure visceral enjoyment that Spin did; what Axis did do, on the other hand, was remind me just how good the first book was, and also keep me enthused for the future release of the third book in this series, Vortex, which I believe comes out at the tail end of this year (which means I’ll probably pick it up sometime around mid-2009, when the mass-market paperback hits and keeps my wallet a little less pained).
I might not have liked Axis as much as Spin, but that’s somewhat akin to not liking A New Hope as much as Empire Strikes Back. One is better than the other, but that doesn’t keep the other from being good in its own right. To be honest, as well, while this book is about the same Hypothetical-influenced universe as the last book, all reviews have pointed out that it’s a different beast altogether – and even keeping in mind this warning, I still found myself moderately disappointed that this book wasn’t, as RCW put it himself, “Spin redux.” Even putting that aside, howeve,r there is something about the novel that just doesn’t feel as good as its prequel, something disappointing about the way the author has structured this book and the revelations within. Almost all of the revelations in this book are anticlimactic, not being what you expect for the most part. Or, rather, they are what you expect, but not for the reasons you expect. for me that lessened the emotional impact that this book might have otherwise had.
I also felt that the plot line regarding Brian, one of the protagonists’ ex-husbands, was improperly concluded. But it’s entirely possible this was done deliberately, to set Brian up for a return in Vortex. Somehow I doubt it, however.

So, in the end, I still recommend Spin to anyone and everyone who wants thoughtful speculative fiction, fiction that’s about the people affected by technology rather than the technology itself. Spin ranks highly as one of my favorite science fiction novels, and indeed as one of my favorite novels. It’s precisely constructed, thoughtful in the extreme, and challenges the reader with questions about just what sort of power the government ought to have, and what it means to be human. It deserves a 9/10 if you need a number rating.
Axis is a good book, despite my disappointment – a 7/10 at least, maybe even an 8/10. But It’s not as good as Spin, and in no way the kind of required reading that Spin was. But if you liked the first one – and I hope anyone who decides to take my recommendation does – and want to see another side of the universe, pick up Axis. Maybe you’ll be less disappointed than I was – and while it fails in following up the stellar Spin, it still stands on its own as a good novel.